Skip to Content

NY.gov Portal State Agency Listing

2011 Consumer Guide to Automobile Insurance

TELEPHONE NUMBERS OF AUTO INSURERS

image of telephoneThe following lists telephone numbers supplied by these insurers at which interested consumers may obtain rating information, or references to where such information may be obtained. Only insurers whose names are included in the 2011 Annual Complaint Ranking, are included in this list.

A toll-free (800) number has been provided where possible. Several insurers did not wish to provide a telephone number, since they work either through exclusive or independent agents. Those insurers indicated as "Agents Listed" should be listed in a local telephone directory under their direct agencies. Those insurers indicated as "Independent Agents" cannot be looked up in a telephone directory, but you can question any number of independent agents to find out if they represent one or more of these insurers. Some insurers are not listed because they are not writing new policies for private passenger auto insurance in New York State at this time.

A few other insurers did not wish to have their numbers published here, as they do not write business to the general public, but only market directly to the members of certain organizations.

x
CompanyGROUPTELEPHONE NUMBER
21st Century Centennial Ins. Co.Zurich 877-310-5687
21st Century Indemnity Ins. Co.Zurich 877-310-5687
21st Century National Ins. Co.Zurich 877-310-5687
21st Century North America Ins. Co.Zurich 877-310-5687
21st Century Preferred Ins. Co.Zurich 877-310-5687
21st Century Premier Ins. Co.Zurich 877-310-5687
21st Century Security Ins. Co.Zurich 877-310-5687
A. Central Insurance Co. 1-866-222-2242
Adirondack Insurance ExchangeTower GroupIndependent Agents
AIU Insurance CompanyAmerican International GroupAgents & Brokers
Allmerica Financial Alliance Ins. Co.Allmerica Financial GroupIndependent Agents
Allstate Indemnity CompanyAllstateAgents Listed, (800) Allstate
Allstate Insurance CompanyAllstate Agents Listed, (800) Allstate
Allstate Property and Casualty Insurance Co.AllstateAgents Listed, (800) Allstate
American Automobile Ins. Co.AllianzIndependent Agents
American Family Home Ins. Co.Midland1-800-MYAMFAM (692-6326)
American Home Assurance Co.American International GroupAgents & Brokers
American Modern Home Ins. Co.Midland866-884-6167*
Amica Mutual Ins Co. 800-242-6422
Associated Indemnity Corp.AllianzIndependent Agents
Assurance Company of AmericaZurich 800-553-7348 & Agents Listed
Automobile Insurance Co. of Hartford CtTravelers GroupInd. Agents and Brokers
Automobile Insurance Plan Any Broker or Agent
AutoOne Insurance CompanyWhite Mountains (1Beacon)Ind. Agents and Brokers
AutoOne Select Ins. Co.White Mountains (1Beacon)Ind. Agents and Brokers
Charter Oak Fire Insurance CompanyTravelers GroupInd. Agents and Brokers
Chartis Property Casualty CompanyAmerican International GroupAgents & Brokers
Chubb IndemnityChubb & Sons Inc.Agents & Brokers
Chubb National Insurance CompanyChubb & Sons Inc.Agents & Brokers
CIM Ins. Corp.GMAC800-331-6380
Citizens Insurance of AmericaAllmerica Financial Corp.Independent Agents
Commerce & Industry Insurance Co.American International Group800-435-0035 or 877-310-5687
Country-Wide Insurance Co. 212-514-7000
Deerbrook Insurance CompanyAllstateAgents Listed, (800) Allstate
Economy Premier Assurance. Co.Metropolitan800- METAUTO or 422-4272
Electric Ins Co.Electric Mutual800-342-5342
Employers Fire Insurance CompanyWhite Mountains GroupIndependent Agents
Encompass Home & Auto Ins. Co.AllstateAgents Listed, 866-760-6050
Encompass Ind. CompanyAllstateAgents Listed, 866-760-6050
Encompass Independent Ins. Co.AllstateAgents Listed, 866-760-6050
Encompass Ins. Co. of AmericaAllstateAgents Listed, 866-760-6050
Encompass P&C Co.AllstateAgents Listed, 866-760-6050
Erie Ins Co.Erie 800-458-0811
Erie Ins Co. of NY Erie 800-458-0811
Esurance Ins. Co.Allstate1-800-ESURANCE (378-7262).
Eveready Insurance Company Brokers
Farm Family Casualty Ins. Co.American National Financial 800-THE-FARM (843-3276)
Farmers New Century Ins CoZurich 800-FARMERS & Agents listed
Farmington Casualty CoTravelers GroupInd. Agents and Brokers
Federal Insurance Co.Chubb & Sons Inc.Agents & Brokers
Fireman's Fund Ins Co.AllianzIndependent Agents
Fireman's Fund Ins Co. of WIAllianzIndependent Agents
First Liberty Ins. Corp.Liberty Mutual800-837-5254
First National Ins. Co. of AmericaSAFECO1-800-4-Safeco
Foremost Ins. Co.Zurich Agents Listed
Foremost P&C Ins. Co.Zurich Agents Listed
Garrison Property & Casualty Ins. Co.USAA800-531-8111
Geico Casualty Insurance Co.Berkshire-Hathaway1-800-861-8380
Geico General Insurance Co.Berkshire-Hathaway1-800-861-8380
Geico Indemnity CompanyBerkshire-Hathaway1-800-861-8380
Government Employees Ins CoBerkshire-Hathaway1-800-861-8380
Granite State Insurance CompanyAmerican International Group800-435-0035 or 877-310-5687
Graphic Arts Mutual Ins. Co.Utica NationalIndependent Agents
Great Northern Ins. Co.Chubb & Sons Inc.Agents & Brokers
Hanover Insurance CompanyAllmerica Financial Corp.Independent Agents
Hartford Accident & Indemnity Co.Hartford F&CAgents Listed
Hartford Casualty Ins. Co.Hartford F&CAgents Listed
Hartford Fire Insurance CompanyHartford F&CAgents Listed
Hartford Ins. Co. of IllinoisHartford F&CAgents Listed
Hartford Ins. Co. of the MidwestHartford F&CAgents Listed
Hartford Underwriters Insurance CompanyHartford F&CAgents Listed
Homeland Ins. Co. of NYWhite Mountains GroupIndependent Agents
IDS Property Casualty Ins. Co.American Express800-842-3344
Illinois National Insurance CompanyAmerican International GroupAgents & Brokers
Insurance Co. of the State of PAAmerican International GroupAgents & Brokers
Integon Casualty Ins. Co.GMAC800-331-6380
Integon National Ins. Co.GMAC800-331-6380
Integon Preferred Ins. Co.GMAC800-331-6380
Kemper Independence Ins. Co.UnitrinIndependent Agents
Landmark Ins. Co.American International GroupAgents & Brokers
Liberty Insurance Corp.Liberty Mutual800-837-5254
Liberty Mutual Fire Ins Co.Liberty Mutual800-837-5254
Lincoln General Ins. Co.Kingsway GroupAgents listed
Long Island Ins. Co. Ind. Agents and Brokers
Main Street America Assurance Co.Main Street America Independent Agents
Maryland Casualty CompanyZurich 800-553-7348 & Agents Listed
Massachusetts Bay Ins. Co.Allmerica Financial Corp.Independent Agents
Mercury Casualty Company 877-2-Mercury
Metropolitan Casualty Insurance Company.Metropolitan800- METAUTO or 422-4272
Metropolitan General Insurance CompanyMetropolitan800- METAUTO or 422-4272
Metropolitan Group Prop. & Cas. Ins. Co.Metropolitan800- METAUTO or 422-4272
Metropolitan Property & Casualty Ins. Co.Metropolitan800- METAUTO or 422-4272
MIC Property & Casualty Ins. Corp.GMAC800-331-6380
Motors Insurance Corp.GMAC800-331-6380
National Continental Ins. Co.Progressive1-800-Progressive
National General Assurance Co.GMAC800-331-6380
National General Insurance CompanyGMAC800-331-6380
National Surety CorpAllianzIndependent Agents
National Union Fire Ins. Co. of PittsburghAmerican International GroupAgents & Brokers
Nationwide Assurance Co.Nationwide1-877-669-6877 or local agents
Nationwide General Ins. Co.Nationwide1-877-669-6877 or local agents
Nationwide Insurance Company of AmericaNationwide1-877-669-6877 or local agents
Nationwide Mutual Fire Ins. Co.Nationwide1-877-669-6877 or local agents
Nationwide Mutual Ins. Co.Nationwide1-877-669-6877 or local agents
Nationwide P & C Ins Co.Nationwide1-877-669-6877 or local agents
New Hampshire Ins. Co.American International GroupAgents & Brokers
New South Ins. Co.GMAC800-331-6380
New York Central Mutual Fire 1-888-234-6926
NGM Ins. Co.Main Street AmericaIndependent Agents
Northern Assurance Company of AmericaWhite Mountains GroupIndependent Agents
Northern Insurance Co of NYZurich 800-553-7348 & Agents Listed
Old Dominion Insurance CompanyMain Street AmericaIndependent Agents
OneBeacon America Ins. Co.White Mountains GroupIndependent Agents
OneBeacon Ins. Co.White Mountains GroupIndependent Agents
Pacific Indemnity CompanyChubb & Sons Inc.Ind. Agents and Brokers
Peerless Ins Co.Liberty Mutual800-837-5254
Pennsylvania General Ins. Co.White Mountains GroupIndependent Agents
Phoenix Insurance Co.Travelers GroupInd. Agents and Brokers
Praetorian Insurance CompanyQBE212-422-1212
Preferred Mutual Ins. Co. Independent Agents
Progressive Advanced Ins. Co.Progressive1-800-Progressive
Progressive Casualty Ins. Co.Progressive1-800-Progressive
Progressive Halcyon Ins. Co.Progressive1-800-Progressive
Progressive Home Ins. Co.Progressive1-800-Progressive
Progressive Max Insurance CompanyProgressive1-800-Progressive
Progressive Northern Ins. Co.Progressive1-800-Progressive
Progressive Northwestern Insurance CompanyProgressive1-800-Progressive
Progressive Preferred Ins. Co.Progressive1-800-Progressive
Progressive Specialty Ins Co. Progressive1-800-Progressive
Property & Casualty Ins Co. of HartfordHartford F&CAgents Listed
QBE Ins. CorpQBE212-422-1212
Republic-Franklin Insurance CompanyUtica NationalIndependent Agents
Response Insurance CompanyUnitrin800-518-2894
Response Worldwide Direct Auto Ins. Co.Unitrin800-518-2894
Response Worldwide Insurance CompanyUnitrin800-518-2894
SAFECO Ins. Co. of AmericaSAFECO1-800-4-Safeco
SAFECO Ins. Co. of IndianaSAFECO1-800-4-Safeco
SAFECO National Ins CoSAFECO1-800-4-Safeco
Sentinel Ins. Co. Ltd.Hartford F&CAgents Listed
Standard Fire Insurance CompanyTravelers GroupInd. Agents and Brokers
State Farm Fire & Casualty Insurance Co. State FarmAgents Listed
State Farm Mutual Auto Insurance Co. State FarmAgents Listed
State-Wide Insurance Co. 800-499-JOIN (499-5646)
Travco Insurance CompanyTravelers GroupInd. Agents and Brokers
Travelers Casualty Co of ConnecticutTravelers GroupInd. Agents and Brokers
Travelers Commercial Insurance CoTravelers GroupInd. Agents and Brokers
Travelers Home & Marine Ins. Co.Travelers GroupInd. Agents and Brokers
Travelers Indemnity Company Travelers GroupInd. Agents and Brokers
Travelers Indemnity of AmericaTravelers GroupInd. Agents and Brokers
Travelers Indemnity of CTTravelers GroupInd. Agents and Brokers
Travelers Property Casualty Co. of AmericaTravelers GroupInd. Agents and Brokers
Travelers Property Casualty Ins Co Travelers GroupInd. Agents and Brokers
Tri-State Consumer Ins Co. 800-JOIN NOW (564-6669)
Truck Insurance ExchangeZurich 800-553-7348 & Agents Listed
Trumbull Insurance CompanyHartford F&CAgents Listed
Twin City Fire Insurance CompanyHartford F&CAgents Listed
United Financial CasualtyProgressive800-288-6776 or 776-4737
United Services Automobile AssociationUSAA800-531-8111
Unitrin Advantage Ins. Co.UnitrinIndependent Agents
Unitrin Auto & Home Ins. Co.UnitrinIndependent Agents
Unitrin Direct Ins. Co.UnitrinIndependent Agents
Unitrin Direct Property and Casualty Co.UnitrinIndependent Agents
Unitrin Preferred Ins. Co.UnitrinIndependent Agents
USAA Casualty Insurance CompanyUSAA800-531-8111
USAA General Indemnity CompanyUSAA800-531-8111
Utica Mutual Insurance CompanyUtica NationalIndependent Agents
Utica National Assurance CompanyUtica NationalIndependent Agents
Utica National Ins. Co. of TexasUtica NationalIndependent Agents
Valiant Ins. Co.Ariel Holdings888-442-4364Agents Listed
Victoria Fire & Casualty Ins CoNationwide800-613-5059 or 798-7783
Victoria National Ins CoNationwide800-613-5059 or 798-7783
Victoria Select Ins CoNationwide800-613-5059 or 798-7783
Vigilant Insurance CompanyChubb & Sons Inc.Agents & Brokers
Warner Ins. Co.Response800-898-2886

*  American Modern Home, Foremost Ins. Co. and Foremost P&C Ins. Co. only write policies for antique, classic cars, motor homes, motorcycles and snowmobiles.

Auto Guide Index |Consumers - Insurance Products | Insurers - Property Insurance